MONADNOCK REGIONAL SCHOOL DISTRICT

Board Meeting Minutes

                                                 August 16, 2005

                              Monadnock Regional Jr. Sr. High School, Swanzey, NH

                      

Present: Richard Thackston, Robin Marra, Colline Dreyfuss, Tim Aho, Jason Hill, Alan Gross, Karen Cota, Bruce McCulley, Jonathan Kenyon, Jeff Friedman, Gene White, B. Tatro and James Carnie. Absent: Charles Johnson and John Morin.  

Also present: K. Dassau, Superintendent, D. Hodgdon, Dir. of Curriculum and L. Biron, Business Manager.  Principals: J. Smith, D. Dahl, K. Craig, K. Carter, M. Young, D. Mousette and B. Tatro.

 

R. Thackston called the meeting to order at 7:00 PM.

 

R. Thackston read the mission statement: “The Monadnock Regional School District will strive to provide the best education for every child.”

 

1          CONSENT AGENDA:

Minutes of July 12, 2005 Board Meeting. MOTION: B. Tatro MOVED to approve the minutes.  SECOND: J. Kenyon.  VOTE: 8.829/0/4.183/1.988. Motion passes.

 

            Minutes of August 8, 2005 Board Meeting. MOTION: K. Cota MOVED to approve the minutes. SECOND: T. Aho. DISCUSSION: C. Dreyfuss asked that the amount of $5400.00 be added to the motion. B. McCulley said that he was not at the meeting but the minutes reflect that he and A. Gross were. They were not.  VOTE: 10.812/0/2.2/1.988. Motion passes

 

2.         CORRESPONDENCE AND ANNOUNCEMENT: R. Thackston informed the Board that he had received a letter from the Roxbury Selectmen and would take this issue up under “New Business.” MOTION: K. Cota MOVED to address the letter from the Roxbury Selectmen at this time in the agenda. SECOND: T. Aho VOTE: 10.179/1.179/1.114/1.988. Motion passes.

 

D. Jewett informed the Board that a mistake had been made on the MS1 and the Monadnock School District was over paid by the Town of Roxbury in the amount of $48,797.00. They are asking that the School District pay it back in two equal payments over the next two years. D. Jewett said that the state will make the adjustments. T. Aho asked if it would show up on each town on their Dec. tax bills. L. Biron said that it would in the amount of $.02 cents or $.03 on a $1000.00. K. Cota stated that the DRA had accepted this and that the only thing needed was the Board’s approval. D. Jewett said yes. MOTION: A. Gross MOVED to ask the Dept. of Education and DRA to make the necessary adjustment to correct the inequitable tax rate for the Town of Roxbury. SECOND: J. Kenyon. DISCUSSION: J. Carnie asked if the number is correct. D. Jewett said that the number came from DRA. B. McCulley asked how it would be rectified. L. Biron said that they would make an adjustment to the valuation to give them back the credit. VOTE: 13.0012/0/0/1.988. Motion passes.

 

K. Dassau informed the Board that there is a request from the attorney for Surry to address the Board under “Public Comments” R. Thackston asked if she is a voter in the District. K. Dassau responded no.

 

3.            STUDENT COUNCIL CONCERNS: No representative present.

 

4.                  PUBLIC COMMENTS: G. Bednarski had signed up to speak, but would wait until the attorney for the Surry group arrives.

 

P. Bauries asked if the information she had requested at the past SAU meeting was available. L. Biron said that he did not have that information with him but would give that information to P. Bauries.

 

D. Bauries had signed up to speak, but would hold his comments.

 

K. Dassau informed the Board that the meeting is being taped by Bob Lund.

 

5.        SCHOOL BOARD COMMITTEE REPORTS:

             Board Committee Reports:

1. Community Relations Report: A. Gross informed the Board that the committee has not met but should be setting a date by the end of this meeting.

 

2.  Facilities Report: C. Dreyfuss informed the Board that the committee had not met since the special meeting on Aug. 8, 2005.

 

3.  Finance Committee: B. McCulley reported to the Board that the committee met at 6:00 PM earlier this evening. He said that the committee would be recommending to the Board that they accept the position of the Facilities Director but they did not vote on the salary. The Finance Committee would not recommend the funding in advance of the next budget cycle. He said that they do not wish to fund the position that they do not have the money for. R. Thackston asked B. McCulley about the $300,000.00 that was withdrawn from the Capitol Reserve and asked why there was not a vote of the district to withdraw the funding. B. McCulley was not aware of that and had no input on that.

 

4.  Policy Committee: G. White passed out a letter from Attorney Hatfield on School Board Vacancies. This is a letter of information and requires no action.

 

5.  The Special Committee to Study the use of Surry School: J. Carnie said that there has been no meeting because of the lawsuit.

 

            6. OTHER SCHOOL BOARD BUSINESS:

A. Action on the Manifest: MOTION: T. Aho MOVED to set the manifest aside until later in the meeting. SECOND: J. Hill. VOTE: 13.012/0/0/1.988. Motion passes.

 

B. New Business: Discussion on the Facilities Director and Vote: C. Dreyfuss was concerned with the decision from the Finance Committee on the Facilities Director. By not funding it, the position was in effect non-existent. C. Dreyfuss asked about the research for the decision. B. McCulley stated that the current budget is not adequate to cover what they have now so it would be inappropriate to add more expenditures. C. Dreyfuss thought that the committee was asked to come up with a compensation package. B. McCulley said next year. C. Dreyfuss said that there is no figure for next year’s budget. R. Thackston asked if anyone would like to discuss the job description. K. Cota commented that the Facilities Committee did their job and the Finance Committee has skirted around the issue. She said that the Board needs that information. She would like the Board to charge the Finance Committee to come up with a compensation package. R. Thackston asked what the will of the Board was. At least half of the process has been completed would anyone like to move the adoption of the job description. MOTION: C. Dreyfuss MOVED to accept the job description for the Facilities Director as presented. SECOND: J. Hill DISCUSSION: T. Aho asked if the Finance Committee received a copy of the job description. C. Dreyfuss said that she sent a copy to the Chair and Vice Chair. VOTE: 10.777/0/2.235/1.988. Motion passes. R. Thackston asked if anyone would like to make a motion on the compensation. MOTION: A. Gross MOVED to accept the recommendation of the Finance Committee. SECOND: B. McCulley. DISCUSSION: K. Cota expressed concern about the Finance Committee’s decision and said that the numbers need to be created for the next budget. R. Thackston said that the motion does not prohibit the Board from asking the Finance Committee to be more specific with a salary and benefits package in the future. The Finance Committee has acted within their charge. R. Thackston commented that he would be voting against the motion. A. Gross said that he spoke to administration and principals and half said that this was not a priority and to have it in the next budget. T. Aho commented that there is a deficit because we are overspending. B. McCulley commented that it would be irresponsible to spend what we do not have. We need to find ways to balance the budget. J. Carnie commented that he did not vote for or against the motion at the Finance Committee meeting. He said that we have a budget that we need to look at to avoid overspending and recommended that the school board look at this for the middle of January. J. Kenyon said that most of the problems with the overspending are with construction. Although he does not support overspending, a Facilities Director is needed to oversee construction spending.  The Finance Committee needs to come up with a benefits package to deal with the real numbers and find a spot when to hire. K. Cota commented that, if we knew what the compensation package would look like, we could form a committee and hire within the next ½ year. R. Thackston asked the Board to reconsider and restate the motion and ask the Finance Committee to develop a compensation package for a Facilities Director. B. Tatro asked for a point of order and commented that the motion deserves to rise or fall on its own merits. B. McCulley commented that the committee is not opposed to creating the position. The committee has the task of looking at the budget’s shortfall and will work on the compensation package in due time. C. Dreyfuss stated that in the June 7, 2005 minutes R. Thackston suggested that the administration look at the job description and compensation package. G. White commented that since June 7, 2005 our finances have changed dramatically because of the septic and this is not at the top of the list. VOTE: 7.496/5.516/0/1.988. Motion passes. MOTION: K. Cota MOVED to charge the Finance Committee to come up with a compensation package by October 4, 2005 in regards to the Facilities Director with documents and rationale to back up. SECOND: J. Hill. DISCUSSION: MOTION: J. Carnie MOVED to amend the motion and adding for the next budgetary cycle. SECOND: B. Tatro. VOTE on the amendment. 9.451/3.561/0/1.988. Motion passes. DISCUSSION on the motion: R. Marra questions the ability of the Finance Committee to do this. The original charge was the administration. C. Dreyfuss commented that she believes that there are other Facilities Directors in the area. She said that she believes that the administration has given the Board a package. B. McCulley said that he does not see a problem with addressing the school board’s directive, if the motion should pass. VOTE: 13.012/0/0/1.988. Motion as amended passes.

 

C.       Old Business: Discussion on the septic: B. Tatro talked to the Swanzey Sewer Commission and will be attending their meeting tomorrow. They told him that they are ahead of schedule. B. Tatro suggested that the Board take a serious look at hooking up now. C. Dreyfuss commented that she did talk to SVE and did receive a proposal in June. B. Tatro said that the engineer commented that they plan to extend the line as far as they can and will let the Board know. K. Cota commented that the Facilities Committee has been working on this since June and it would have been nice to have received this information before. She asked that the information be in writing.

 

R. Thackston informed the Board that he has been informed by the Swanzey Select board that they have not been paid for the building permits from the district. A. Gross asked if they would like it retroactively. R. Thackston said that they would like to be paid for what they have there. A. Gross asked what the past practice has been. R. Thackston said that the Board has not had to pay the full price. R. Thackston said that it is several thousands of dollars that they owe. J. Carnie asked to get the opinion of the attorney. He informed the Board that there was land behind the town hall that the schools gave to the Town of Swanzey and the District asked for dirt and never received it. R. Thackston said that he would convey the message to the Select board. G. White informed the Board that a letter was written and there was no response. R. Marra suggested that we remind the Select board that there is no charge when they use the school buildings.

 

D.       Curriculum Report: D. Hodgdon included information in the Board packets and went over the highlights with the Board. He explained to the Board what curriculum work is being done during the summer. He mentioned the mentoring program which he believes is very important because there will be a number of teachers retiring during the next several years. He informed the Board that a national presenter would be offering a Writing Training Session, which is well subscribed. The Middle School Task Force met for three days in July and decided that it had completed its tasks. D. Hodgdon shared a map of the components of a middle school in Monadnock and a continuum for each component identifying the ideal, acceptable, and unacceptable. M. Young, the Middle School principal, has decided to form an advisory group representing teachers, staff and parents to serve some of the purposes of the Middle School Task Force, which will be suspended.

K. Cota asked about the balance sheet. She said that she was not familiar with the format. L. Biron said that it is an example of what the real balance sheet would look like. K. Cota asked where the Capitol Reserve was. L. Biron said that it has not been loaded. L. Biron read the amounts in the Capitol Reserves. K. Cota commented that the Capitol Reserve had dropped. L. Biron said that it reflects the warrant articles and interest. J. Carnie said that he did not see the MRPSOC information. L. Biron said that he did not give it to Kathy. R. Thackston asked where it was in the manifest. L. Biron said that it was a single item in the manifest. L. Biron said that it is a timing problem.   

 

7. Superintendent’s Report: K. Dassau informed the Board that they will enter into non-public session for litigation and hiring on employees.

 

K. Dassau informed the Board that they are invited to opening day at MRHS on Friday, August 26.

K. Dassau informed the Board that they have been invited to participate in Board     Training sponsored by the MRPSOC Grant.  Information to be forthcoming.

 

K. Dassau wished to thank the Board for supporting his appointment to the Superintendent position. An ad for the position of SAU Director of Special  Services will be coming out soon. He hopes to then appoint an Assistant Superintendent for Monadnock through internal restructuring. He is assessing the SAU support positions as well. He will plan to have a report to the SAU Board in October. 

 

8. Board Chair Report: R. Thackston explained that he has completed his visits to the surrounding Select boards all except Surry. He has been asked to compile the notes for the Board and Select Boards.


 

         9. SETTING UP THE NEXT MEETING’S AGENDA:

1.      Committee Reports

2.      Report from Business Manager (Lounder and Cushing questions.)

3.      Project Director MRPSOC Programs

4.      Report from B. Tatro on Swanzey Sewer Commission

 

        10. Action on the Manifest: MOTION: R. Marra MOVED the manifest in the amount of $1,244,239.17. SECOND: G. White. DISCUSSION: T. Aho questioned a check in the amount of $.03. He also asked about a check to Cushing and Sons and one to Lounder. L. Biron said that he would look into those questions. B. McCulley asked about the Platinum plus card. L. Biron said it is a Bank One MasterCard. T. Aho mentioned Lounder and Cushing because he did not see any bids. He said that the bidding process had not been followed in the past. C. Dreyfuss commented that it was standing policy for $5000.00 or more. R. Thackston commented that the motion could be amended. L. Biron said that Lounder was a 5% retainer from Gilsum, which we agreed to pay after the settlement. It was an agreement. B. McCulley commented that, if we release the checks then we are not following policy. J. Carnie suggested paying the vendors and then get the answers. VOTE: 10.812/1.021/1.179/1.988. Motion passes.   

 

11. SECOND PUBLIC COMMENTS: G. Bednarski asked G. White, the Chair of the Policy Committee, what the lawyer told him about the policy regarding vacancies and the copy that was sent to R. Thackston. G. White said that he does not have it.

 

G. Bednarski commented on an article in the Sentinel regarding the quality of education. He commented on the triple classrooms in the Northern Schools.

 

W. Brown requested that Attorney Rebecca Todd be able to read a letter on behalf of the Surry Education Evaluation Committee. MOTION: J. Friedman MOVED to allow Rebecca Todd to speak on behalf of the Education Evaluation Committee. SECOND: J. Kenyon. DISCUSSION: It was commented that some of the Board’s attorneys are not voting citizens in the district and are allowed to speak. T. Aho asked if there was a copy of the letter. The answer was yes. B. McCulley said that he felt it appropriate because she was speaking on behalf of the Town of Surry. VOTE: 13.012/0/0/1.988. Motion passes. R. Todd read a letter to the Board. The letter was a proposal to resolve litigation. She explained the letter to the Board. K. Dassau explained that the Board’s attorney would meet with them in non-public session on this issue. R. Todd explained that there would be a revote on both issues if the Board were to agree with the proposal. R. Todd explained that, if the Board agrees, the meeting on Friday will be dismissed and cannot be brought up again. The Surry citizens signing the petition want the meeting on the decision, recognizing that the vote might not be changed. N. Moriarty asked what RSA the Board would be going into non-public session for. K. Dassau informed him that it was RSA 91-A:3II(e) Litigation, to discuss the suit against the district. . W. Brown thanked the Board for listening to R. Todd. W. Brown also commented on the fact that his three children will be going to three different schools. He said that there is no transition time. He explained that there was a study committee but citizens were not allowed to participate.

 

A. Gross commented on the excellent article in the Keene Sentinel. He commented on the multi-grades and the test scores in Surry.

 

         R. Thackston asked for a 5-minute recess.

 

12. 9:50 PM Non Public Session. MOTION: C. Dreyfuss MOVED to enter into non-public session for the purpose of hiring new employees under RSA 91 A3II (a). SECOND: J. Kenyon. Roll call: J. Kenyon, A. Gross, J. Carnie, B. McCulley, K. Cota, C. Dreyfuss, J. Hill, T. Aho, G. White, J. Friedman, B. Tatro, R. Marra and R. Thackston. VOTE: 13.012/0/0/1.988. Motion passes.

 

MOTION: J. Carnie MOVED to extend the Board Meeting past 10:00 PM. SECOND: B. Tatro. VOTE: 11.744/1.268/0/1.988. Motion passes.

 

13. 10:02 PM Non-public Session. MOTION: J. Carnie MOVED to enter into non-public session for the purpose of hiring new employees under RSA 91 A3II (a). SECOND: C. Dreyfuss. Roll call: J. Kenyon, A. Gross, J. Carnie, B. McCulley, K. Cota, C. Dreyfuss, J. Hill, T. Aho, G. White, J. Friedman, B. Tatro, R. Marra and R. Thackston.  VOTE: 13.012/0/0/1.988. Motion passes.

 

R. Thackston asked J. Friedman to leave as he was one of the Surry citizens who signed the petition against the district.

 

14. 10:18 PM Non-public Session: MOTION: R. Marra MOVED to enter into non-public session for the purpose of litigation’s under RSA 91 A32:E. SECOND: J. Kenyon. Roll call: J. Kenyon, A. Gross, J. Carnie, B. McCulley, K. Cota, C. Dreyfuss, J. Hill, T. Aho, G. White, B. Tatro, R. Marra and R. Thackston. VOTE: 12.309/0/0/2.691. Motion passes.

 

R. Thackston informed the public after the non-public session that no action was taken during non-public session.

 

15. ADJOURNMENT: MOTION: T. Aho MOVED to adjourn at 10:58 PM. SECOND: J. Kenyon. VOTE: 11.288/.703/1.021/1.988. Motion passes.

 

         Respectfully submitted,

 

Laura L. Aivaliotis

         MRSD Secretary